Little did I know that I was diving into a controversy.
My Amish neighbors are experts with horses and take great care of their steeds. Apparently, other people have had the misfortune of witnessing something to the contrary.
It is not wise to lump an entire race or ethnic group into a pot and label them. That is called profiling.
Each person in every people group should have the right to be seen and known for who they are as an individual, not pre-judged.
Beautifully fit workhorses on an Amish farm. |
I would love to mediate between those who have never met an Amish person and my Amish neighbors.
First of all, let me acknowledge the truth in some of these accusations. Yes, unfortunately, there are some individuals in every people group that are cruel to animals or other humans. But, let's not accuse all NFL players of using dogs wrongly because we heard about a few who did.
The first thing you should know about the Amish and why their horses look so thin: Amish use a breed of horse that is naturally thin. The best breeds for pulling a buggy are trotters and pacers, horses that have been bred for hundreds of years for use on racetracks. This would be much akin to the dog breed, Grayhound. What if you owned a Grayhound and your neighbors didn't understand that these dogs are born looking hungry.
I promise that you will find many a fat pony and overweight draft horse on Amish farms all over America. There is a good explanation for this: draft horse and pony breeds are naturally "easy keepers" unlike trotting horses. Workhorses would be more like Bulldogs and ponies like Pugs.
I have traveled all over the U.S.A. visiting Amish communities and I have found that most Amish horses are dearly loved by their owners. I will admit that have witnessed a minority that are less than enthused about their horses, and even a few that are harsh.
If you know of an individual that mistreats an animal, you should be bold enough to speak to them about it. Please, don't hide behind your computer and toss accusations against an entire people group.
Instead, take time to look for the good in people. You will be pleasantly surprised when you personally get acquainted with Amish people.
oh THNAK YOU for this post. We have Amish friends, who are the kindest dearest and smartest horse people you would ever meet. I love talking "horses" with them...I can't tell you the times that I have felt I needed to "speak" up for my friends... good for you..... this was a great blog!!!!!
ReplyDeleteHello Sue, I'm super happy to hear that your experience is much like mine! I'm sure there are some horror stories out there, but it is so unfair to pin tags on people. Thank you for your endorsement.
ReplyDeleteIt's wonderful that their horses still work for a living!
ReplyDeleteHorses, like dogs, are happy when they have a job!
DeleteThank you for saying this. I agree. And whoever did the drawing of the horse did a great job.
ReplyDeleteI'm happy to have so many positive replies. And the drawing is one that I did for my novel, English River. Thanks!
DeleteAll people in a category should not be lumped together, as you said. I would think that the majority of Amish would take good care of their horses, since they are such a big part of their lives.
ReplyDeleteThank you for your comment, Norma. Most Amish folks I know want good quality horses and are pleased to have them in top condition.
Delete